Skip to main content
March 23, 2025 | Car Accidents

Why You Should Never Settle a Car Accident Claim Without a Lawyer

Section 1: Understanding the Stakes

Certainly! Insurance companies are skilled at protecting their bottom line, and they often use various tactics to minimize the payout for your claim. Here are some common strategies they employ:

1. Offering Quick Settlements
After an accident, insurers may rush to offer you a settlement before the full extent of your injuries or damages is known. While the money might seem appealing in the short term, these early offers are often much lower than what you’re entitled to.

2. Downplaying Your Injuries
Insurance adjusters might argue that your injuries are not as severe as you claim. They could request excessive documentation or even try to use pre-existing conditions to reduce the compensation amount.

3. Using Recorded Statements Against You
Insurers may ask for a recorded statement under the guise of needing “more information.” They can then cherry-pick your words or take them out of context to devalue your claim.

4. Delaying the Process
By dragging their feet on resolving your claim, they may pressure you into accepting a lower settlement out of frustration or financial need.

5. Shifting Blame
Adjusters might try to place partial or full blame for the accident on you, reducing your payout. This can be especially tricky in states with comparative fault laws, where compensation decreases based on your level of responsibility.

6. Questioning Medical Treatments
They may argue that your treatments were unnecessary or excessive, aiming to pay less than the total medical expenses you’ve incurred.

7. Requesting Unnecessary Documentation
Asking for extensive and often irrelevant paperwork can create delays and wear you down, making you more likely to settle.

What legal options do I have against insurance tactics?

You have several legal options to counter insurance company tactics and protect your rights after a car accident. Here’s an overview:

1. Hire a Lawyer
A personal injury attorney specializes in navigating these disputes. They know how to combat unfair practices and can negotiate with the insurance company on your behalf.

Lawyers can file lawsuits if negotiations fail, ensuring your claim gets the attention it deserves.

2. File a Complaint
If you suspect unethical behavior or bad faith tactics, you can file a complaint with your state’s insurance department. Each state has regulatory agencies to oversee insurance practices.

3. Bad Faith Lawsuits
Insurance companies are required by law to act in good faith when handling claims. If they deliberately delay, underpay, or deny claims without valid reasons, you may sue them for bad faith practices.

A successful lawsuit can result in compensation beyond your claim, such as punitive damages.

4. Demand Arbitration
In some cases, disputes can be resolved through arbitration—a more informal process than going to court. Arbitration can help settle disagreements faster.

5. Provide Evidence
Always document everything related to your accident: photos, medical records, police reports, and communications with the insurance company. Solid evidence strengthens your position.

6. Seek Mediation
Mediation involves a neutral third party helping to negotiate a fair resolution. This is a less adversarial route compared to litigation.

7. Litigation
As a last resort, you can pursue a lawsuit against the at-fault driver or their insurer in civil court. This may be necessary if the insurer is unwilling to provide fair compensation.

The key is to act proactively and not let an insurance company pressure you into accepting an unfair settlement. Legal representation significantly increases your chances of achieving a favorable outcome.

What should I look for when hiring a personal injury attorney?

Choosing the right personal injury attorney can make a huge difference in your case. Here are some key factors to consider when hiring one:

1. Specialization in Personal Injury Law
Look for an attorney who focuses specifically on personal injury cases. Specialists are more familiar with the intricacies of these cases, including dealing with insurance companies and assessing claim values.

2. Experience and Track Record
Ask about their years of experience, especially in handling cases similar to yours (e.g., car accidents, slip and falls).

Review their success rate and history of settlements and verdicts. A strong track record can indicate their ability to secure fair compensation.

3. Reputation
Check online reviews and testimonials from former clients to gauge their professionalism and communication skills.

Look into peer ratings or awards they may have received, which can indicate respect within the legal community.

4. Resources and Network
A good attorney should have access to resources like investigators, medical experts, and accident reconstruction specialists to strengthen your case.

5. Communication Skills
Evaluate their responsiveness and willingness to answer your questions during consultations. Clear, honest communication is essential for a good attorney-client relationship.

6. Fee Structure
Most personal injury attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you win your case. Confirm their fees upfront to avoid surprises later.

7. Trial Experience
Ensure they’re comfortable going to trial if necessary. Some attorneys focus only on settlements, which could impact the outcome if your case proceeds to court.

8. Personal Connection

Trust your instincts about whether you feel comfortable working with them. The process can be lengthy, and you’ll want someone you trust and can communicate with easily.

9. Free Consultations
Many personal injury lawyers offer free initial consultations. Use this opportunity to ask about your case, their approach, and what to expect if you move forward.

10. Local Knowledge
An attorney familiar with the local laws, courts, and judges in your area will have an added advantage in navigating your case.

Taking the time to thoroughly research and meet with potential attorneys will ensure you find someone who’s the right fit for your needs.

You cannot get any better than Jackie.

“You cannot get any better than Jackie. Completely professional, fair, understanding and trustworthy. We were facing an almost impossible situation but with Jackie’s tenacity and God’s grace it all turned in our favor. I highly recommend Jackie Ferguson Graham.”

- Shane

Very professional and courteous.

“Very professional and courteous. They kept me informed and walked things through step by step. Took care of my case in a timely manner as well. I’m very pleased.”

- Joshua

He is nothing but the best.

“Randy took good care of our son in his case. He is nothing but the best. If You ever need someone who you can count on to do his best for you, he is the one to pick. Thank You for your fine job!”

- Steph

I would highly recommend working with this firm.

“I can’t say enough good about working with Ms. Jackie Graham Ferguson. She was very professional, personable, and seemed to really care. Her knowledge within her field of expertise, coupled with her years of experience, are evident from the first minute you begin talking to her. I would highly recommend working with this firm. A+++++”

- Michael Matthews

She always made herself available.

“Mrs. Ferguson is a outstanding , knowledgeable, and honest attorney. She was there when my family was at its lowest and has never wavered. She always made herself available. She was dedicated to our case and worked hard. I would recommend Jackie with out hesitation for any legal matters. My family will always turn to her, and will be as dedicated to her as she was to us.”

- Joseph Morgan
Request Free Consultation

Send Us a Message

Attorneys available 24/7 to answer your legal questions.

Send a Message

Call our office today At

(256) – 534 – 3435

We Will Be Able To Answer Any Questions You Have

Call Us Today